Amityville Toybox

Mark Popejoy

Mark

Julia Farrell

Julia

Jennii Caroline

Jennii

Breana Mitchell

Breana

Daniel Joseph Stier

Dan (as Daniel Steir)

Tony Brown

Tony

Jade Michael LaFont

Jade

Britany Dailey

Brittany

Schuylar Craig

Schuylar

Cheyenne King

Aunt Cheyenne

Jeanne Kern

Grandma

Colby Coash

Mark's Father

Jason Bracht

Driver

Jake Brokoven

Passenger

Eric Moyer

DeFeo

Emily Smith

DeFeo's Daughter

Sarah Moshman

TV Saleswoman